Customer Service and Claims

Company Customer Service Number Claim Reporting Number
AIG 888-315-8977 888-244-6143
Allied Insurance 800-282-1446 800-282-1446
Auto-Owners Call Agent 800-252-4626
Bell Prarie 800-526-4252 Call Agent
Dairyland Insurance 800-526-4252 800-338-2487
Erie Insurance 800-458-0811 x 3000 800-367-3743
Forrest Mutual 815-657-8279 Call Agent
Frontier Mutual 800-343-1868 Call Agent
Grinnell Mutual 800-362-2041 x 2455 877-467-2252
Hartford Insurance 800-771-8557 800-243-5860
Hasting Mutual 800-442-8277 800-442-8277
Hagerty Insurance 800-922-4050 Call Agent
Mercury Insurance 800-503-3724 800-503-3724
Midwest Family Mutual Call Agent Call Agent
Ohio Casualty 800-843-6446 800-843-6446
Pekin Insurance 800-322-0160 877-735-4611
Progressive Insurance 800-776-4737 800-776-4737
Standard Mutual 866-469-3968 888-288-8899
Unitrin 800-456-0448 888-253-7834

What We Insure

Auto Insurance

The right auto insurance policy can help get you back on the road quickly if your car is damaged or destroyed by accident, fire, theft, or other covered event.


If you own your home, you may not be required to hold home insurance but if you have a mortgage, your lending instruction will most likely require home insurance


As an independent insurance agency, we take pride in reviewing your options with multiple insurance companies and comparing protection and prices.

Term Life

Protect your family and your future with the right personal, health & life insurance. Planning to keep your family secure - today tomorrow, and down the road?

Copyright 2017 Gerdes-McMillan Insurance All Rights Reserved. For more information, feel free to | Contact Us